Facebook Instagram Twitter YouTube

Trans* Liberation is Only Possible If We Overthrow Capitalism

On Transgender Day of Rememberance, let us honor the Trans* lives that have been stolen by a rotten and oppressive system. The only way to ensure true liberation is to end the oppressive system of capitalism.

Ezra Brain

November 20, 2020
Facebook Twitter Share

More Trans* people have been murdered in the U.S. so far in 2020 than in the entirety of 2019. This is the reality for Trans* people under capitalism. The Trans* community is overwhelmingly disadvantaged by capitalism and tends to be poorer, more precarious, and more vulnerable.

In the U.S., around 30 percent of Trans* people live below the poverty line. Trans* people face severe housing discrimination and more than 10 percent have faced eviction. Unhoused Trans* people are also far more likely to be unsheltered than cisgendered unhoused people. Prior to the current economic crisis, the unemployment rate in the Trans* community was double the national average and 44 percent of Trans* people who were working were underemployed.

In 2018, 35 percent of Trans* youth reported having attempted suicide in the past year, compared to 7 percent of cisgender teens. In that same study, 31 percent of Trans* teens reported that they had experienced sexual violence within the past 12 months. Further, Health care is often inaccessible, unaffordable, or abusive for many Trans* people. 

Trans* people are also disproportionately policed and imprisoned. 22 percent of Trans* people report being harassed by police officers while 7 percent of Black Trans* people were sexually assaulted by police officers. In prisons, Trans* people face horrific rates of abuse and assault

These statistics paint a harrowing picture of life for Trans* people under capitalism.

Rainbow capitalists would have us believe that all of this is because of individual bigotry and slight structural flaws. The answer, these queer servants of capital tell us, is that we need to ensure greater Trans* visibility by putting more Trans* people on boards of directors and billboards. They would have us believe that simply seeing a Trans* person in a Starbucks commercial will somehow benefit the Trans* community. “Look at us,” they want to tell us, “we’re increasing visibility, we’re helping solve the problem.”

But visibility is not liberation.

That isn’t to say that visibility is not important. But normalizing our oppression by putting a Trans* face on capitalism does nothing to put an end to systemic oppression and poverty. The solution isn’t to have more Trans* CEOs but to end the system as a whole — because the oppression of Trans* people under capitalism isn’t a bug, it’s a feature.

By design capitalism is an inherently imbalanced system that is based around a minority ruling over the majority. In order to do this, they need to find ways to divide the working class against itself so that they don’t question why they continue to work within a system that exploits them. From this need to divide sprung the exploitation of distinctions on race, gender, and sexual orientation. The working class was turned against itself by the bourgeoisie and their allies in the church and media. 

Capitalism reinforces social relations that help capitalism function. For example, the gender binary props up the concept of the nuclear family, which capitalism relies on for (largely uncompensated) reproductive labor. Identities beyond that binary are then marginalized in an attempt to protect a social structure that is better for capitalism. This is carried over into the workplace where discrimination against Trans* people helps to maintain a pool of precarious labor for capitalists to tap into. 

Given this, it is impossible to imagine a capitalism that doesn’t oppress because capitalism is based upon exploitation. The ruling class needs to maintain a system that allows them to enrich themselves off of our labor. This requires one class that is exploited and another that exploits. Even if every single Fortune 500 Company had a Trans* CEO, this would still be the way that the system works. And, given that Trans* people are overwhelmingly working class and vulnerable, they will continue to be oppressed.

Trans* liberation is not possible within the bounds of capitalism. If we want to end the horrific rates of Trans* poverty or lower the rates of suicide among Trans* youth or end police violence against Trans* people of color, then we have to end the system of capitalism.

We must overthrow capitalism for Marsha P. Johnson, Sylvia Rivera, and all the other Trans* heroes of the past who fought for liberation.

We must overthrow capitalism for Layleen Polanco, Tony McDade, and all the other Trans* victims of police violence. 

We must overthrow capitalism for the Trans* people sleeping on the streets, struggling with unemployment, and for all of the countless Trans*  youth who are wondering if their lives are worth living. 

Today is Transgender Day of Rememberance. Let us remember the brave struggles of our predecessors and carry their struggle forward, into the streets and into our workplaces; into our organizations; and into the future because as long as capitalism continues to stand, we will only see more devastation for the Trans* community.

Facebook Twitter Share

Ezra Brain

Ezra is a NYC based theatre artist and teacher.

Gender & Sexuality

Spain: Mass Mobilizations against Homophobic Murder Met with Government Repression

After a homophobic hate crime, thousands take to the streets.

A Black person in a black crop top is holding a rainbow flag. They are in front of a parade.

Five Things We Should Fight For This Pride

This Pride weekend, we remember and celebrate the Stonewall uprising led by trans women of color. Although we have won some concessions, we have so much more to fight for. We must look past all of the trappings of rainbow capitalism — which seek to distract us from the work we still have to do — and understand that our role, like that of our elders before us, is to fight for queer liberation and the end of capitalism.

Tatiana Cozzarelli

June 27, 2021

Democrats and Banks Won’t Steal Juneteenth or Pride

From Juneteenth to Stonewall, the capitalists want to co-opt Black radicalism. Don't let them.

Carmin Maffea

June 25, 2021

Queers for Socialist Revolution: Join the Left Voice Contingent at the Queer Liberation March

During Pride month, we remember and celebrate the Stonewall uprising led by trans women of color against the police. Around the world, from Myanmar to Colombia, queer folks have been on the front lines of fighting against the government, austerity, and police repression. In the U.S., queer folks were at the forefront of last year’s […]

Left Voice

June 16, 2021

MOST RECENT

Pro-Palestine protesters at a march in Philadelphia. Palestinian flags in the background while someone holds up a sign that says "Freedom for Palestine."

Temple University Rank and Filers Release Palestine Solidarity Statement

Rank and filers at Temple University in Philly are demanding their union local and national fight to end all support for Israel and join the cause of Palestinian workers.

Jason Koslowski

August 3, 2021
Four healthcare workers, including co-author of this article Mike Pappas, stand in scrubs and masks in front of an Amazon warehouse holding signs in support of better wages and safer working conditions for Amazon workers.

What Billionaire Space Flights Mean to Healthcare Workers

While the Covid-19 pandemic continues to rage around the globe and climate disaster is destroying the planet, billionaires are taking joyrides to space. Two healthcare workers who worked throughout the pandemic respond.

Mike Pappas

August 2, 2021
An older woman wearing a hat holds a sign that reads "No More Unjust Revictions: I Lost My Home of 36 Years"

Eviction Moratorium Expired, Millions Face Homelessness

After a half-hearted attempt to extend the eviction moratorium failed, the House of Representatives left for summer vacation.

Emma Lee

August 2, 2021
Image of rubble and a lot of smoke in the background. People stand in front of the wreckage.

Joe Biden is Bombing Somalia

Despite claims to reduce drone strikes, Joe Biden is bombing Somalia.

K.S. Mehta

August 1, 2021